Indianapolis radio listeners got a taste of culinary daring this week when WIBC’s morning duo Hammer and Nigel wrapped up their popular “Condiment Week” series with a truly daring experiment. After testing mustard, ranch, mayo and ketchup on a Little Debbie Christmas Tree cake, the pair turned to the city’s iconic St. Elmo Steak House cocktail sauce – the same sauce that famously clears sinuses when paired with a shrimp cocktail.
From Mild to Wild: The Week in Review
The series began with a modest 6 out of 10 rating for mustard on the sugary cake, followed closely by ranch at 5.9, mayo hovering around a 5, and ketchup lagging at a disappointing 3. Those scores set the stage for a bold finale that would push the flavor envelope even further.
Spicy Finale
For Friday’s showdown, Nigel insisted on using “the most Indianapolis topping possible” – the signature cocktail sauce from St. Elmo Steak House. Hammer initially declined to participate, but after a bit of coaxing he took a bite. The reaction was immediate and memorable: the sauce’s heat cut through the cake’s sweetness, creating a surprising balance that left both hosts laughing and reaching for water.
While the exact numeric rating was not disclosed in the broadcast, the hosts described the experience as “unexpectedly enjoyable” and noted that the sauce’s tangy, peppery profile actually complemented the cake’s vanilla frosting. They also warned listeners that the sauce’s intensity may be too much for younger palates, suggesting it’s best suited for adventurous adults at holiday gatherings.
What It Means for Your Holiday Party
WIBC encourages listeners to watch the full video on its YouTube channel, where the tasting is captured in real time. After seeing the hosts’ reactions, many fans have asked whether they should try the combination at their own Christmas parties. The station’s community feedback has been mixed, with some praising the creativity and others preferring more traditional desserts.
Regardless of personal preference, the segment underscores a broader trend of local media embracing light‑hearted, food‑focused content that brings families and friends together during the holiday season. It also highlights Indianapolis’ pride in its culinary landmarks – St. Elmo Steak House remains a beloved institution, and its cocktail sauce continues to inspire conversation beyond the restaurant’s walls.
Where to Find the Full Series
Listeners can revisit the entire Condiment Week series, including the earlier mustard and ranch experiments, on 93.1 WIBC’s YouTube channel. Each episode runs just a few minutes, making it easy to catch up during a coffee break or while decorating the tree.
As the holiday season unfolds, WIBC plans to feature more local flavor stories, reinforcing its commitment to community‑centric programming that celebrates Indianapolis culture and encourages families to explore new traditions together.
Original reporting: 93.1 WIBC (Indianapolis) — read the source article.