Panama City Beach, Fla. – State Attorney Larry Basford announced that prosecutors will not pursue criminal charges against Carlos Suarez‑Contreras, a 26‑year‑old illegal immigrant from Venezuela, for the May 17 crash that killed 82‑year‑old Deborah Murphy outside a Publix parking lot.
Why charges were not filed
Basford explained that while the driver’s actions were “careless and negligent,” Florida law requires proof that the driver knowingly operated with a suspended license and acted with reckless disregard. The investigation found that Suarez‑Contreras’ Georgia driver’s license had been canceled only a day before the accident, and prosecutors could not establish that he was aware of the cancellation at the time of the crash.
Without evidence of culpable negligence, the state could not meet the threshold for vehicular homicide or manslaughter. The case was therefore dismissed, and Suarez‑Contreras remains in ICE custody pending deportation.
Details of the incident
Surveillance video shows Murphy walking toward her car in a crosswalk, facing away from the reversing Toyota 4Runner. The vehicle struck her, pushed her to the ground, and continued backing up, running her over. Murphy was taken to a hospital and died from blunt‑force injuries within an hour.
Suarez‑Contreras was initially charged with driving with a canceled license and causing a death, a third‑degree felony, and was held without bond as a potential flight risk. However, the inability to prove that he knew his license was suspended led to the dismissal.
Family’s reaction and calls for change
Murphy’s daughters, Amy Edge and Beth Schulz, expressed devastation and frustration, saying they feel “let down by the state of Florida.” They plan to advocate for changes to state law and immigration‑enforcement procedures to prevent similar tragedies.
“We don’t want this to happen to anyone else in the United States,” Edge said, emphasizing the family’s desire for deportation of the driver rather than a criminal trial.
Legal context
Florida’s 2023 law invalidates driver’s licenses issued to illegal immigrants in certain states, but Georgia is not among those listed. Basford noted that the legislation’s limited scope contributed to the prosecutorial challenges.
The case also highlights the broader debate over immigration enforcement and state‑level licensing policies. Advocates for stricter enforcement argue that the current system allows individuals without legal status to operate vehicles, while critics caution against policies that may disproportionately affect immigrant communities.
Next steps
Suarez‑Contreras was transferred to ICE custody on November 15 and remains slated for removal proceedings. His defense attorney, Russell Ramey, expressed satisfaction with the dismissal.
The Murphy family says they will continue to push for legislative reforms and greater accountability in law‑enforcement investigations.
Original reporting: Fox News (HLL/CB) — read the source article.