Indiana Attorney General Todd Rokita is facing a federal lawsuit from NetChoice, a trade group representing TikTok, YouTube, Meta, Google and Amazon, over a state law that could keep thousands of Hoosier children off social media unless they obtain verifiable parental consent. The suit, filed this week, argues the law violates the First Amendment and seeks a court declaration that the statute is unconstitutional.
Under the law, which the Indiana General Assembly passed earlier this year, any new social‑media account must verify a user’s age and Indiana residency. If the user is under 16, the platform must obtain parental consent before the account can be created. Consent may be demonstrated by providing a Social Security or credit‑card number, or a copy of a driver’s license. The statute also mandates that platforms remove “addictive features” such as autoplay, livestreaming and infinite scrolling from accounts used by minors.
Supporters say the law is a direct response to the tragic 2023 death of Fishers teenager Hailey Buzbee, who met her alleged killer online. “You might get sued when you do it, but here, you take that risk because of how tragic it is when even one instance of that occurs,” Governor Mike Braun said at the time, emphasizing the state’s duty to protect children.
NetChoice’s Director of Litigation, Paul Taske, told reporters, “We are actually asking the court to specifically declare that the law is unconstitutional,” and added that the group is not opposed to measures that protect minors, but believes the law overreaches constitutional limits. He noted that many law‑enforcement agencies lack funding to investigate cyber‑crimes, suggesting that education and parental tools are preferable first‑line defenses.
Rokita’s office responded, “NetChoice has a long track record of suing when states pass laws to hold their members responsible for the addictive features used to attract our kids. (The law) is part of Indiana’s effort to address the dangers of addictive social media features that go after children. As we always do, we will continuously, vigorously and successfully defend the law against this challenge.”
Bob Behning, the law’s author and former House Education Chair, acknowledged the risk of litigation, likening the fight to “taking on David and Goliath,” but said momentum for protecting children remains strong. The lawsuit could take several years to resolve, and the law is still slated to go into effect on Jan. 1, 2025 unless a court halts it.
What’s next: The case will be heard in federal court, where a judge will decide whether Indiana’s age‑verification and parental‑consent requirements stand. If the court upholds the law, Indianapolis families will need to navigate new verification steps before their children can join platforms such as TikTok or Instagram. If the law is blocked, the state may seek to revise the statute or pursue alternative protections for minors.
Sources: wibc.com