At a Tuesday meeting in Pinedale, the Sublette County Board of Commissioners voted 3‑2 to invalidate a building permit for billionaire Joe Ricketts’ proposed luxury resort on his Upper Hoback River Road ranch. The decision follows a warning from County Attorney Clayton Melinkovich that targeting Ricketts while allowing comparable developments to proceed could breach foundational legal principles.
Legal counsel stresses equal treatment
In an Oct. 7 email obtained by WyoFile, Melinkovich reminded commissioners that the Constitution and Wyoming law require “treat similarly situated people the same.” He cited the Declaration of Independence, the Fifth and Fourteenth Amendments, and the Wyoming Constitution to underline the point.
“I witnessed two instances yesterday where Sublette County, through its board of commissioners, made decisions that treated similarly situated people differently,” Melinkovich wrote. He highlighted two prior zoning changes—Mountain Meadow and Moyes family subdivisions—where the two‑year development requirement had also lapsed, yet the county did not pursue termination proceedings.
Commissioners defend their authority
Melinkovich concluded his email with a clear endorsement of the board’s authority, stating, “Can the County succeed in terminating the zone change? Yes, it is possible. Will my office vigorously defend your decision in the event that the commission terminates the zone? Yes, we certainly will. Does the County lose its credibility when it treats similarly situated individuals differently? Yes, full stop.”
Commissioner Doug Vickrey, who voted to terminate the resort zoning, said he is acting on behalf of the community. “I looked around yesterday, and I saw a house full of folks concerned about what’s happening. I didn’t see many supporters for Mr. Ricketts,” Vickrey told WyoFile.
Ricketts’ development history in the Hoback Basin
Joe Ricketts, founder of TD Ameritrade and owner of the Chicago Cubs, has pursued a series of projects in the Hoback Basin for more than five years. In addition to the proposed “Confluence” resort—a three‑level, 47,000‑square‑foot complex with lodging, a restaurant, a spa, and an underground parking garage—Ricketts purchased the 33‑acre Safari Club International property along Granite Creek in 2024, planning to open a guest ranch called The Hawken. He also acquired the Timberline Ranch near Merna and the Renegade subdivision on Greys River Road, which is currently the subject of a civil lawsuit alleging fraud.
Neighbors filed an appeal against the Confluence permit, citing concerns about wildlife‑friendly construction requirements and the project’s scale. During the meeting, Jackson attorney John Graham argued that Ricketts had already achieved “substantial development” on a prior attempt, presenting a June 2023 letter from former Sublette County Planner Dennis Fornstrom as evidence.
Next steps and upcoming hearing
The commissioners set a contested‑case hearing for Feb. 9, 2027, to consider whether to reverse the resort zoning entirely. Jackson attorney Leah Schwartz, representing the neighboring residents, urged the board to undo the zoning, while the board opted to keep the hearing open for further deliberation.
By that date, the composition of the Board will have changed. Newcomers Andy Nelson and Robin Schamber unseated Vickrey and Commissioner Mack Bradley in the August primary election. Vickrey said he expects the new commissioners to review the information and make a decision they deem just.
Community perspective
Local residents expressed mixed feelings. Some neighbors, including Dan and Yvonne Bailey, voiced concerns about the resort’s impact on the small Bondurant community, which numbers roughly 100 people. Others remain hopeful that any development will respect the area’s natural beauty and wildlife.
The county’s actions underscore a commitment to applying zoning rules consistently, a principle that resonates with many Wyoming citizens who value limited government and fair treatment under the law.
Original reporting: Oil City News (Casper WY) — read the source article.