New Haven announced Friday that it has reached a $30 million settlement to resolve two federal wrongful‑conviction lawsuits – one filed by George Gould and the other by the estate of Ronald Taylor. The agreement, reached on Nov. 13, will pay $18 million to Gould and $12 million to Taylor’s estate, pending approval by the New Haven Probate Court.
Both men were convicted of felony murder and related charges in the July 4, 1993 killing of Eugenia Vega inside her Grand Avenue bodega. Decades later, Vega’s son told relatives he had killed his own father, casting doubt on the original convictions. The sole eyewitness testimony came from a Fair Haven sex worker who, according to the settlement filing, was interrogated while in severe heroin withdrawal and was promised heroin in exchange for a statement that implicated Gould and Taylor. Police found no physical evidence linking the two men to the crime.
In 2010, a Connecticut Superior Court judge granted habeas corpus petitions for Gould and Taylor on grounds of actual innocence, ordering their release. The state appealed, the Connecticut Supreme Court vacated the decision, and a second habeas trial denied the petitions. Gould returned to prison in 2011, while Taylor died of cancer that same year after being allowed to remain at home due to his terminal diagnosis. Gould was finally released again in 2021 after a judge modified his sentence, and the Conviction Integrity Unit of the Office of the Chief State’s Attorney recommended vacating both convictions in 2024. Gould sued the city and eight former detectives in 2025.
The settlement is the fourth and fifth federal civil‑rights lawsuit the city has resolved in the past three months, following settlements with Adam Carmon ($16.5 million), Vernon Horn ($15.25 million) and Marquis Jackson ($15.25 million). Law firms representing the plaintiffs – Neufeld Scheck Brustin Hoffmann & Freudenberger, LLP; the Law Offices of Richard Emanuel; and the Law Office of Michael A. Jefferson – issued a joint statement saying the payments will be made “with prejudice” and that all claims against the city will be released.
Mayor Justin Elicker, quoted in the city’s press release, said, “While it took far too long to get to this point, today we are acknowledging and addressing these past miscarriages of justice, and we are deeply sorry for the decades of pain and suffering that Mr. Gould and Mr. Taylor have experienced.” Gould added, “I am relieved to have finally reached the end of my legal ordeal. No amount of money could make up for the decades I spent wrongfully incarcerated.” Attorney Nick Brustin of NSBHF commented, “Only after a massive jury verdict against the City of New Haven for its custom and practice of illegal misconduct in the Morant case did the City come to its senses and settle Mr. Gould’s and Mr. Taylor’s case.”
What’s next: The settlement must first be approved by the New Haven Probate Court for Taylor’s estate. Afterward, the city’s Litigation Settlement Committee will review the agreement, and the Board of Alders will need to vote to bond the full $30 million. The city has indicated it intends to bond the entire amount.
Sources: newhavenindependent.org