When a couple relocated to a new Texas town a year ago, they turned to the NextDoor app to learn about local parks, traffic and even the occasional rattlesnake. Among the neighborhood posts, a solicitation for a women’s book club caught the eye of a longtime avid reader who had never participated in such a group.
Joining the Club
Despite reading roughly fifty books a year and maintaining a detailed Goodreads profile, she admitted that a busy career, introversion and a touch of imposter syndrome had kept her out of book clubs until her early fifties. She responded to the NextDoor invitation, completed a brief email statement about her reading habits, and endured a Zoom interview with two existing members. The interview, she humorously notes, felt like a screening for “psychopaths or alcoholics seeking free wine,” and she was reminded to keep politics out of the conversation.
What She Learned
After being accepted, she began attending a monthly Tuesday evening meeting in members’ living rooms. Six surprising observations emerged:
- The book itself mattered less than the discussion. Of the twelve titles read, seven were by authors she had never encountered, and three she disliked. Yet the conversations sparked new insights.
- Selecting a book is a challenge. Members have varied criteria—some prefer “bucket‑list” titles, others look for four‑star Goodreads ratings, and many favor backlist works that can be borrowed or bought cheaply. To bring order, she created a spreadsheet vetting system.
- Preferences differ. Books she found terrible were beloved by others, prompting her to reconsider her judgments.
- People are sensitive about their choices. While she is quick to judge, she learned not to equate a person’s worth with their selection, coining a T‑shirt slogan: “You are not your book selection and your book selection is not you.”
- Reading ahead is essential. She discovered that trying to discuss a 400‑page novel without having read it left her without insights, so she now reads the book within a week of the meeting and takes notes.
- Re‑reading can be rewarding. Though she rarely re‑reads, the club’s collective experience with Steinbeck’s The Grapes of Wrath—a novel she had never tackled—offered a powerful connection to her family’s Dust Bowl heritage.
Books the Club Explored
The group’s reading list includes titles such as The First Ladies (Benedict & Murray), The Correspondent (Virginia Evans), Angle of Repose (Wallace Stegner), The Master Butcher’s Singing Club (Louise Erdrich), The Children Act (Ian McEwan), Sick Puppy (Carl Hiaasen), The Impossible Thing (Belinda Bauer), The Grapes of Wrath (John Steinbeck), Mad Mabel (Sophie Hepworth), Eleanore of Avignon (Elizabeth DeLozier), These Is My Words (Nancy E. Turner) and The Borrowed Life of Frederick Fife (Anna Johnston).
Community Impact
Beyond literary enrichment, the experience has helped her develop diplomacy skills, understand diverse life stories, and forge friendships with women who were strangers a year ago. The club illustrates how a simple neighborhood invitation can nurture community bonds, encourage respectful dialogue, and provide a wholesome outlet for families and individuals seeking connection in a new town.
Original reporting: Texarkana Gazette — read the source article.