South Carolina Circuit Court Judge Debra McCaslin on Friday denied Alex Murdaugh’s motion to dismiss the murder indictments that have been pending since July 2022. The judge concluded that the evidence presented, even without the disputed grand‑jury testimony on blood spatter and shotgun ammunition, is sufficient to support the charges.
Key Findings
Judge McCaslin faulted former S.C. Law Enforcement Division (SLED) agent David Owen for overlooking a laboratory report that was addressed to him before his testimony. She determined that the record did not show Owen knowingly testified falsely, nor that prosecutors intentionally presented false evidence. The defense also failed to demonstrate that the disputed testimony substantially influenced the grand jury’s decision to indict.
The order leaves in place all four indictments returned by a Colleton County grand jury in July 2022, charging Murdaugh with two counts of murder and two counts of possessing a weapon during the commission of a violent crime. The victims were his wife, Maggie Murdaugh, 52, and his younger son, Paul Murdaugh, 22, who were shot at the family’s Moselle property on June 7, 2021.
Background
The South Carolina Supreme Court unanimously overturned Murdaugh’s 2023 murder convictions in May after finding that former Colleton County clerk of court Rebecca “Becky” Hill improperly influenced jurors, depriving him of a fair trial. Judge McCaslin moved the retrial to Sumter County in September.
During a November 13 hearing in Lexington, defense attorney Jim Griffin argued that Owen presented two false forensic links: alleged blood spatter on the white T‑shirt Murdaugh was wearing, and the claim that shotgun shells recovered at the scene matched those used to kill Paul. SLED’s November 10, 2021 lab report indicated no human blood was identified in the shirt cuttings, a detail omitted from the materials given to blood‑stain‑pattern analyst Tom Bevel. After reviewing better photographs, Bevel later identified more than 100 stains he considered consistent with spatter, but he acknowledged that chemical treatment of the shirt could have produced a false negative.
Regarding the ammunition, Judge McCaslin noted that no shotgun recovered from the residence contained the exact combination of shells used in Paul’s killing. Investigators did find shells consistent with both types used elsewhere on the property. The grand‑jury proceedings were not recorded, so the court could not determine precisely what Owen told jurors. The judge attributed any inaccuracies to confusion or imprecise descriptions, finding no evidence of intentional fabrication.
Prosecution’s Position
Lead prosecutor Creighton Waters argued that independent evidence—video from Paul’s phone placing Murdaugh at the kennels minutes before the deaths, cellphone and digital timeline data, .300 Blackout casings linked to those found near Maggie’s body, and a family rifle of the same caliber—provides probable cause. Under the South Carolina Supreme Court’s 1994 State v. Thrift standard, dismissal for grand‑jury error requires a showing that the misconduct substantially influenced the decision or that there is grave doubt the decision was free from such influence.
Judge McCaslin also rejected the defense’s claim that prosecutors improperly used a separate State Grand Jury to gather evidence for the murder case, finding the overlap with the financial crimes investigation fell within the scope of that inquiry.
Next Steps
The parties are scheduled to return to court in Sumter County on January 20, 2027, for the next pre‑trial hearing. The retrial is set to begin April 5, 2027.
Original reporting: FITSNews — read the source article.