Buffalo, N.Y. – Commissioner Erika Shields returned Friday to the pressing issue of officer shortages in the Buffalo Police Department (BPD). Citing the department’s heavy reliance on overtime to meet minimum staffing levels, Shields said she is actively pursuing a pro bono staffing study to identify the department’s true personnel needs.
Why a staffing study is needed
“We inherited this, and we’re gonna clean it up,” Shields told reporters. “The department clearly needs more police officers on the street handling 911 calls.” The BPD has not conducted a comprehensive staffing analysis since its formation, leaving officials uncertain whether the force should number 600, 900, or another figure.
Recruitment challenges
Compounding the problem, the department has not held a police exam since 2023, and the next scheduled exam is not expected until 2027. Without a recent exam, the BPD cannot draw from a fresh pool of candidates. Shields outlined a two‑pronged recruitment strategy: tapping the Erie County active list of potential recruits and opening the department to lateral hires from other agencies.
Seeking a pro bono solution
Because a formal staffing study can be costly, Shields is reaching out to accredited policing institutes to see if a university or research center will conduct the analysis without charge. She referenced a similar effort during her tenure as Chief of Police in Atlanta, where Georgia Tech Ph.D. students completed an 18‑month study that compiled extensive data points.
Current staffing levels
The BPD is currently budgeted for 813 sworn officers. However, the reliance on overtime suggests that the department is operating below that authorized strength, stretching existing officers thin and potentially impacting response times.
Community impact
Residents have voiced concerns about delayed response times and the safety implications of an understaffed police force. By securing a thorough, data‑driven staffing study, the commissioner hopes to present a clear, evidence‑based plan to the city council and the public, ensuring that Buffalo’s neighborhoods receive the protection they deserve.
Next steps
Shields said the search for a pro bono partner is already underway. Once a study is secured, the department will analyze the findings and develop a recruitment and budgeting plan that aligns with the city’s fiscal realities while prioritizing public safety.
“I don’t think anybody knows with accuracy whether the police department should be 600 people or 900 people,” Shields added. “That’s why we need solid data to guide our decisions.”
Original reporting: WKBW 7 Buffalo (Buffalo section) — read the source article.