Hartford, Conn. – On Friday, U.S. District Judge Vernon Oliver issued a preliminary injunction that stops Connecticut from enforcing four sections of Senate Bill 397, a law passed by Democratic lawmakers earlier this year. The blocked provisions would have given the state’s Inspector General authority to investigate and criminally prosecute federal immigration officers and would have made it a misdemeanor for ICE agents to wear masks while performing official duties.
Judge cites constitutional conflict
In his written order, Judge Oliver, a former state Superior Court judge appointed to the federal bench by President Joe Biden in 2023, said the challenged sections likely run afoul of the Supremacy Clause, which ensures that federal operations are not chilled by state prosecution and that federal officers are immune from state prosecution when acting within the scope of their federal authority.
Oliver added that the Department of Justice under President Trump’s administration is expected to prevail in the lawsuit the federal government filed in May, reinforcing the principle that states cannot dictate how federal officers conduct their duties.
Republican lawmakers celebrate the decision
State Republican leaders quickly praised the ruling, noting they had warned Democratic colleagues that the bill would face constitutional challenges. “We warned that the law violates the Constitution’s Supremacy Clause by attempting to regulate federal officers while they carry out their official duties. Lo and behold, a federal judge right here in Connecticut agrees with what we had warned about,” said Sen. Rob Sampson of Wolcott, Sen. Eric Berthel of Watertown and outgoing Senate Minority Leader Stephen Harding of Brookfield.
The Republicans criticized the Democratic effort as political theater, arguing that when one party controls nearly every lever of power in Hartford, the temptation to ignore constitutional constraints becomes far too common.
Democratic response and concerns
Gov. Ned Lamont, who signed the bill into law in May, expressed disappointment with the ruling and condemned what he described as ICE’s treatment of Connecticut residents. “Masked, armed agents without visible badges have surrounded cars in traffic and stormed homes and workplaces, rounded up parents dropping kids off at school and picked up a Cheshire high school student whose father aided troops in Afghanistan,” said Cathryn Vaulman, Lamont’s communications director.
Lamont urged the new Congress to protect immigrants and strengthen oversight of the Department of Homeland Security. “We are disappointed by today’s ruling and condemn ICE’s treatment of Connecticut residents,” Vaulman wrote.
Democratic lawmaker defends the bill
Rep. Steven Stafstrom, D‑Bridgeport and co‑chair of the legislature’s Judiciary Committee, argued that the judge did not fully consider the balance between the Supremacy Clause and the state’s inherent police powers. “I respect the court, but I fear today’s ruling leaves Connecticut less safe, because it blocks the tools S.B. 397 gave us to investigate deaths involving federal officers and to make sure people know who is exercising police power in their communities,” Stafstrom said.
He added that the court’s decision is preliminary and that he will work with colleagues and the attorney general’s office on next steps, emphasizing that accountability is essential for community safety.
Attorney General’s office reviews ruling
Attorney General William Tong’s office responded briefly, indicating it is reviewing the decision and evaluating next steps.
The injunction represents a significant setback for Connecticut Democrats who sought to increase oversight of ICE agents, especially as ICE’s enforcement activities have intensified nationwide during President Trump’s second term.
Original reporting: The Connecticut Mirror — read the source article.