What do you order first at a place that takes both raw fish and Gulf oysters equally seriously? That question trips up a lot of first-timers at Umi Sushi & Oyster Bar on Vista Ridge Mall Drive, and honestly, it’s a good problem to have.
Ask for Pam. She’s been behind the host stand and sometimes floating tables long enough to have an actual opinion on what’s clicking that night. On a recent Wednesday she steered a couple away from the tempura roll special — “It’s fine, but that’s not why you’re here” — and straight toward the oyster shooter and the Umi roll. That kind of candor is rarer than it should be in a strip-mall sushi spot, and it sets the tone for the whole experience.
The room itself is dim without being pretentious about it. Booth seating lines the far wall, and the bar up front gives you a clear view of the sushi chefs working. The crowd skews local — you’ll see work shirts next to date-night outfits, families with teenagers who apparently convinced their parents that sushi counts as dinner. The vibe lands somewhere between neighborhood staple and something a little more considered than that.
Start with the oysters if they have them on ice. The Gulf selections rotate, and the staff will tell you where they’re from. A half-dozen runs you around $18 to $22 depending on the day. Follow that with the tuna tataki, which arrives fanned out and finished with a ponzu that’s sharp without being overwhelming. It’s the kind of dish that makes you slow down and actually taste what you ordered.
The rolls are where most people spend their money, and there’s a reason the menu runs long. The Volcano roll — shrimp tempura inside, baked scallop on top with a sauce that leans spicy-sweet — is the crowd anchor, the thing people reorder every visit. But if you’ve been here before, push yourself toward the more straightforward nigiri. The salmon is clean, the yellowtail has texture, and you get a better sense of how the kitchen actually operates when you’re not buried in sauce.
Expect to spend $35 to $55 per person with a drink, more if you lean into the oysters or sake list. Weekend evenings fill up, and they don’t take reservations for parties under six, so arriving by 6:30 p.m. saves you a wait. The lunch menu runs leaner and faster — a solid option if you’re working nearby and want something that isn’t a drive-through.
Lewisville has enough sushi options that none of them gets to coast. Umi earns its regulars the straightforward way: consistent fish, a staff that actually pays attention, and a kitchen that doesn’t rush you through the meal. Pam will probably be there. Take her advice.