New Haven, Conn. – On Friday the city confirmed a $30 million settlement with former inmate George Gould and the estate of the late Ronald Taylor, ending two long‑standing wrongful‑conviction lawsuits. The agreement, reached on Nov. 13, will pay $18 million to Mr. Gould and $12 million to Mr. Taylor’s estate, pending approval by the New Haven Probate Court.
Background of the cases
Gould and Taylor were convicted of felony murder in connection with the 1993 killing of Eugenia Vega in a Grand Avenue bodega. Decades later, new testimony from Vega’s son suggested he was responsible for his father’s death. The original convictions rested on a single eyewitness statement from a Fair Haven sex worker who later disclosed that she was interrogated while in severe heroin withdrawal and was promised heroin in exchange for her testimony. No physical evidence linked the two men to the crime.
In 2010 a Connecticut Superior Court judge granted habeas corpus petitions on grounds of actual innocence, ordering their release. The state appealed, the Connecticut Supreme Court vacated the ruling, and a second habeas hearing denied the petitions. Mr. Gould returned to prison in 2011; Mr. Taylor died of cancer that same year after being allowed to remain at home.
Mr. Gould was finally freed in 2021 after a sentence modification and a 2024 decision by the Conviction Integrity Unit of the Office of the Chief State’s Attorney to vacate both convictions. He sued the city and eight former detectives in 2025, leading to the current settlement.
Settlement details and city response
The settlement was negotiated by Neufeld Scheck Brustin Hoffmann & Freudenberger, LLP, the Law Offices of Richard Emanuel, and the Law Office of Michael A. Jefferson. In a joint statement the city and the plaintiffs agreed that, in exchange for the payments, Mr. Gould and Ms. Mary Murphy‑Taylor, executor of Mr. Taylor’s estate, will withdraw their complaints with prejudice and release all claims against the City of New Haven and its employees.
Mayor Justin Elicker praised the agreement as a step toward “justice and fairness for New Haveners.” He said, “While it took far too long to get to this point, today we are acknowledging and addressing these past miscarriages of justice, and we are deeply sorry for the decades of pain and suffering that Mr. Gould and Mr. Taylor experienced.” He added that the settlement should provide Mr. Gould’s family with a measure of peace, even though Mr. Taylor did not live to see his conviction vacated.
The mayor also emphasized that the city’s current police force is not implicated in the historic wrongdoing, noting that today’s officers “adhere to the highest professional standards and put their lives on the line to protect our residents.”
Financial impact on the city
The $30 million settlement joins three earlier civil‑rights payouts—$16.5 million to Adam Carmon, $15.25 million each to Vernon Horn and Marquis Jackson—bringing total settlements to $77 million. Including interest over a projected 20‑year bonding period, the city estimates repayment will exceed $116 million.
State law limits compensation from Connecticut to a formula based on median household income, but municipal settlements are not capped, resulting in higher payouts. The city is seeking additional state assistance, noting that the state appealed the original vacating of Gould and Taylor’s convictions.
To fund the settlement, the city will seek approval from its Litigation Settlement Committee and the Board of Alders, which is expected to bond for the full amount. The city also noted that it lacked insurance coverage for this type of incident at the time of the 1993 investigation, and it must pay the plaintiffs’ attorneys’ fees under state law.
Other pending wrongful‑conviction claims
In May, a jury awarded $38 million to Stefon Morant in a wrongful‑conviction trial; the city is currently appealing that verdict. Two additional lawsuits remain unresolved: Alder Troy Streater’s $100 million claim against the city and detectives, and a claim by Charles Coleman Jr. The State of Connecticut has awarded $19.5 million in compensation for these three cases.
Mayor Elicker called on the state to assume a larger share of the financial burden, arguing that “the impact of these past wrongs is being felt in the city’s finances today.” He reiterated the city’s commitment to fiscal responsibility while addressing historic injustices.
Looking ahead
The settlement underscores New Haven’s effort to correct historic errors while safeguarding its budget. City officials say the agreement allows the municipality to move forward, focusing on current public‑safety priorities and responsible financial stewardship.
Original reporting: New Haven Independent — read the source article.