GREEN BAY, Wis. – In a 10‑page opinion issued Thursday, Brown County Circuit Judge Marc Hammer dismissed a civil lawsuit that accused billionaire Elon Musk and the political group America PAC of offering financial incentives to influence the 2025 Wisconsin Supreme Court election.
Case background
The lawsuit was filed by the Wisconsin Democracy Campaign, along with private plaintiffs Paul Gagliardi and Deborah Patel. The plaintiffs alleged that Musk’s representatives promised $100 to anyone who signed a petition opposing “activist judges” and offered $1 million to two individuals who voted for former Attorney General Brad Schimel in the race against incumbent Justice Susan Crawford.
Judge’s ruling
Judge Hammer concluded that the plaintiffs failed to demonstrate the legal standing required to bring the case. He wrote, “Plaintiffs’ displeasure with Defendants’ conduct and further steps taken to mitigate Defendants’ effects on the State of Wisconsin and the rest of the United States is not enough. Mere disagreement or frustration with Defendants’ conduct is insufficient to confer standing.” Because the plaintiffs could not show a concrete injury, the court granted the defendants’ motion to dismiss.
Relation to prior criminal review
The dismissal follows an August decision by state prosecutors not to pursue criminal election‑bribery charges against Musk for the same alleged offers. Both rulings underscore the difficulty of proving illegal election influence when the alleged conduct does not meet the statutory definition of a bribe under Wisconsin law.
Impact on the Supreme Court race
Justice Susan Crawford retained her ten‑year seat on the Wisconsin Supreme Court, defeating former Attorney General Brad Schimel. The court’s composition remains unchanged, and the decision does not affect the outcome of the election itself.
Legal context
Wisconsin law requires a plaintiff to show a specific, personal injury to have standing in civil court. The judge’s opinion emphasizes that policy disagreements or general dissatisfaction with a candidate’s tactics do not satisfy that requirement.
What’s next?
With the civil case dismissed, the plaintiffs may consider appealing the decision, though the standing issue is likely to remain a significant hurdle. Observers note that the ruling may set a precedent for future challenges to political spending and incentive offers in state elections.
Original reporting: FOX 11 WLUK Green Bay (local) — read the source article.