Taos, NM – The New Mexico Supreme Court’s disciplinary board voted on Nov. 2 to permanently disbar former prosecutor Cosme Ripoll, citing a pattern of egregious courtroom behavior that undermined a defendant’s right to a fair trial.
Misconduct that prompted disbarment
Ripoll, who served for decades as both a defense attorney and a prosecutor in the 8th Judicial District, was found to have engaged in several violations during the 2022 trial of Desiree Lensegrav. Lensegrav had been convicted of first‑degree murder, conspiracy to commit murder, kidnapping and tampering with evidence for the 2020 killing of Joseph Morgas.
During that trial, Ripoll presented physical evidence taken from Morgas’s remains that emitted a strong odor, forcing the court to adjourn for the day. He also repeatedly used disparaging language, calling Lensegrav a “bruja” and a “witch,” and referred to another defendant, Daniel Chavez, as a “killer,” a “macho man,” and a “prowling, scoping mad dog in a wife‑beater T‑shirt.”
Legal fallout for the defendant
Lensegrav appealed her conviction, arguing that Ripoll’s conduct denied her a fair trial. The New Mexico Court of Appeals agreed, vacating all of her convictions and releasing her from prison.
Attorney Luz Valverde of the Office of the Public Defender described the misconduct as “extreme and pervasive,” noting that the prosecutor’s actions “bordered on fiction” and eroded courtroom decorum.
Potential impact on other cases
Target 7, a local investigative outlet, reviewed 15 homicide and sexual‑assault convictions handled by Ripoll. One of those cases involved Daniel Chavez, whose murder conviction was upheld despite his appeal citing Ripoll’s “excessive use of bloody photos to invoke an emotional reaction.” While Chavez’s appeal was denied, legal analyst John Day said the disbarment raises the possibility that other convictions could be revisited if similar misconduct is proven.
“The defendant certainly might want to have his case looked at again. But again, the misconduct would have to rise to the level of something that led to an unfair trial. And it’s not certain,” Day said.
Administrative response
Marcus Montoya, the 8th Judicial District Attorney, confirmed that Ripoll will remain employed in a non‑attorney administrative support role, primarily assisting with case intake. Montoya emphasized the office’s commitment to “pursue justice fairly and impartially” and to maintain public trust through accountability.
Attempts by Target 7 to contact Ripoll and his attorney for comment were unsuccessful.
What this means for New Mexico’s legal system
The disbarment underscores the high ethical standards expected of prosecutors, who are often described as “ministers of justice.” It also serves as a reminder that misconduct, even at the local level, can have far‑reaching consequences for defendants and the integrity of the judicial process.
State officials and legal watchdogs say the case will likely prompt a review of other prosecutions handled by Ripoll, ensuring that any further violations are identified and addressed promptly.
Original reporting: KOAT Albuquerque — read the source article.