Missoula residents will not see Montana’s newly enacted SB 437 enforced for now after Missoula County District Judge Leslie Halligan issued a preliminary injunction on Tuesday. Halligan said the plaintiffs are likely to succeed on claims that the law violates constitutional rights to privacy and equal protection, according to the Montana Free Press.
SB 437, sponsored by Republican Sen. Carl Glimm of Kalispell, defines “sex” solely by the type of gamete a person is capable of producing, tying it to primary sexual anatomy. The bill also states that sex is “in no way influenced or defined by one’s psychological state, behavior, expression, or personal identity,” and that the term “gender” must be considered a synonym for sex, not for gender identity or expression. The law would affect more than 60 sections of state statutes, including driver’s licenses, marriage licenses, and anti‑discrimination protections, the Montana Free Press reported.
Rep. Zooey Zephyr, a Democrat from Missoula, warned that the measure erases intersex, nonbinary and Two‑Spirit people “from cradle to grave.” The law’s impact on local services and identity documents is a direct concern for Missoula families and community organizations that serve LGBTQ+ residents.
The legislation passed the Legislature in April 2025 but sat unsigned for nearly a year. House Speaker Brandon Ler finally signed it on March 24, 2026, and Governor Greg Gianforte signed it the same day, giving the bill an immediate effective date, according to the legislative record cited by the Montana Free Press. Upper Seven Law, which represents transgender, intersex and Two‑Spirit Montanans, filed the lawsuit on April 6 and sought a preliminary injunction on June 19.
In her ruling, Halligan compared SB 437 to the earlier SB 458, a 2023 law that was previously struck down for its “state‑mandated binary classification of sex.” While the state argued that SB 437 differs because it does not require individuals to disclose private information, Halligan found the operative effect to be the same and therefore likely unconstitutional.
The governor’s office referred reporters to a March 31 statement from Gianforte and Speaker Ler, which described the law as codifying a “commonsense, immutable, biologically‑based definition of sex, male and female” and pledged to defend it in court. No further comment was offered.
Halligan’s order is temporary; it bars enforcement of SB 437 while the lawsuit proceeds unless she lifts the injunction or a higher court overturns it. The case is expected to continue through the state courts, and the plaintiffs may appeal the decision.
What’s next: The litigation will move forward in Missoula County Court, with a likely hearing on the merits of the constitutional challenge later this year. Both state officials and advocacy groups have indicated they will continue to monitor the case closely, as its outcome could affect a wide range of state regulations that impact Missoula residents.
Sources: gayety.com