New York City residents saw a new warning on Amazon’s website and mobile app on Wednesday. The pop‑up, which appears when users open the retailer, says the proposed Delivery Protection Act could raise prices by as much as five dollars per order and slow delivery times.
What the proposed law would do
The Delivery Protection Act would require Amazon to directly employ the workers who currently deliver packages through third‑party delivery service providers (DSPs). The bill aims to give those workers the benefits and protections that come with full‑time employment, a goal championed by Mayor Zohran Mamdani and labor groups such as the International Brotherhood of Teamsters.
Amazon’s response
Amazon argues the legislation would force the company to consider moving its operations out of the city. In the warning message the company says, “We’d be forced to consider moving our operations outside of the city – that would likely mean slower and more expensive delivery for millions of customers in New York City, while also threatening small businesses and their thousands of employees.” The retailer also notes that more than 40 small delivery businesses and over 5,000 New Yorkers could lose their livelihoods if the bill becomes law.
City officials push back
City Council Speaker Julie Menin called the Amazon ads “deceptive,” accusing the company of scaring shoppers with a blanket $5 fee claim. “To put out an ad that falsely claims that if you purchase something on Amazon you’re gonna get a $5 fee every single time is completely deceptive,” Menin said.
Mayor Mamdani, who endorsed the bill in August, responded on social media, stating, “Amazon is a multi‑trillion‑dollar company. If Jeff Bezos adds $5 to your order, it’s not because of the City Council’s efforts to protect workers’ rights and keep our streets safe. It’s greed.”
Labor and community concerns
The proposal has garnered support from labor advocates who say the current contractor model leaves delivery workers without health benefits, paid leave, or job security. At the same time, some civil‑rights groups and the National Urban League have warned that many of the DSPs are Black‑owned businesses, and a ban on third‑party providers could disproportionately affect those owners.
Speaker Menin acknowledged those concerns, saying, “I am mindful of the fact that many of the DSPs are Black and brown owned, and I want to ensure their ability to operate.” She indicated she is open to modifying the bill, possibly dropping the outright ban on third‑party delivery companies and instead licensing and regulating warehouse operations.
What’s next?
The bill is slated for a council vote later this month. If passed, Amazon says it will continue to lobby against the measure and encourage New Yorkers to contact their council members. The debate highlights the tension between protecting worker rights and preserving the cost‑effective delivery model that many city residents rely on.
Original reporting: Brookhaven News – ABC7 New York — read the source article.