A federal civil‑rights suit was filed Thursday in the U.S. District Court in Eugene, alleging that the University of Oregon (UO) illegally revoked a job offer after a background check uncovered a misdemeanor conviction related to a pro‑Palestine protest.
Background and complaint
Nic Francisco‑Kaho’onei, a resident of Multnomah County who uses they/them pronouns, applied in August 2024 for the position of program director of UO’s Women’s Center, a campus hub for gender‑related events and student resources. The university extended the offer in November 2024, contingent on a standard background check.
The check flagged a second‑degree disorderly‑conduct conviction from April 2024, stemming from an incident in which Francisco‑Kaho’onei blocked traffic on Interstate 5 during a pro‑Palestine demonstration. The defendant pleaded guilty in November 2024, received a $50 fine and was ordered to complete 40 hours of community service.
University’s rationale
According to the complaint, UO initially rescinded the offer on Dec. 4, stating the charges had not yet been adjudicated and the university did not wish to wait. After Francisco‑Kaho’onei provided court documents confirming the conviction, the university again withdrew the offer on Dec. 19, asserting the “very recent conviction is relevant to the Program Director position.” The complaint argues the university never explained how the misdemeanor, tied to protected speech, related to job duties.
UO’s Human Resources FAQ notes that criminal convictions are not an automatic disqualification and are evaluated case‑by‑case, considering the nature of the offense, time elapsed, and relevance to the position. The university has not responded to requests for comment.
Legal claims
Francisco‑Kaho’onei alleges the university violated their First Amendment right to free speech and the Equal Protection Clause by selectively enforcing its hiring policy against political activity. The lawsuit seeks a jury trial, damages for lost wages, emotional distress, attorney fees, and a declaratory judgment that the university’s actions were unconstitutional.
Defendants include Mark Schmelz, UO’s vice president and chief human‑resources officer, Angela Lauer Chong, vice president of student life, and Jimmy Howard, associate vice president for student life and dean of students. Schmelz is slated to leave Oregon for a position at Cornell University in January.
Broader context
The case arrives amid ongoing debates over campus free‑speech policies and the treatment of student‑activists. Earlier, Francisco‑Kaho’onei was terminated from a director role at Portland State University’s Women’s Resource Center in April 2025, a dismissal they attribute to public support for Palestine.
Both universities maintain that hiring decisions consider a range of factors and are not intended to punish lawful protest. Critics, however, argue that the timing and rationale suggest a punitive response to political expression.
What’s next
The lawsuit will proceed through the federal court system, where a judge will determine whether the university’s actions constitute unlawful retaliation for protected speech. The outcome could set a precedent for how higher‑education institutions handle background checks involving political activism.
Original reporting: Homepage – Lookout Eugene-Springfield — read the source article.