Chicago – The Illinois Commerce Commission (ICC) approved only $40.3 million of the $144 million rate increase request submitted by Peoples Gas on Thursday, a decision that will keep the impact on monthly household bills modest.
Rate request sharply reduced
Peoples Gas originally sought a $202 million increase but trimmed the request to $144 million after slower‑than‑expected progress on its pipe‑retirement program. Administrative law judges had earlier proposed a reduction to $66.2 million. The ICC’s final order settles on just $40.3 million, less than one‑third of the amount the utility asked for.
Impact on consumers
If the full request had been approved, Chicago households could have seen an additional $7‑8 on their monthly gas bills. With the ICC’s reduction, the actual increase will be far lower, though Peoples Gas said it is still analyzing the order to determine the precise bill impact, which will begin in December.
Commissioners stress affordability
Commissioners highlighted the importance of keeping gas service affordable for Chicago residents. They noted that Peoples Gas had not demonstrated that its proposed spending was reasonable or prudent. The order also sets a 9.48 % return on equity for shareholders, up from the prior 9.38 % but below the 10.1 % the utility sought.
Utility’s response
Peoples Gas called the decision “surprising and extremely disappointing,” saying the ICC ignored the recommendations of its own expert staff and the administrative law judges. The company warned that the order would cut $25 million in what it described as “critical day‑to‑day safety work.”
Consumer and advocacy reaction
Citizens Utility Board Executive Director Sarah Moskowitz condemned the ruling, calling the utility’s profit drive “brazen” given its record earnings in seven of the past nine years. She said the decision could be a harbinger of stricter limits on Peoples Gas in the future.
Pipe‑retirement mandate remains
The spending reduction largely relates to the ICC‑mandated pipe‑retirement program, which requires the removal of over 1,000 miles of aging iron gas pipes by 2035. Advocates had urged the commission to relax the mandate, arguing that replacement is wasteful and that alternatives such as pipe relining or home electrification could be more cost‑effective. While the ICC did not overhaul the requirement, Chair Doug Scott said Peoples Gas was using an “unnecessarily narrow” definition of pipe replacement, leading to higher costs.
Future oversight
Chair Scott noted that the ICC is ready to provide clarification on permissible retirement methods and encouraged the utility to engage with the commission outside of formal rate cases. The ICC will review progress on the pipe‑retirement program in a Safety Monitor report due in March 2027.
North Shore Gas also affected
In a related decision, the commission reduced North Shore Gas’s $8.7 million rate request by roughly 78 %, approving only about $1.9 million for the utility that serves roughly 166 000 customers in Chicago’s northern suburbs.
Peoples Gas delivers natural gas to nearly 900 000 customers across Chicago, making the ICC’s decision a significant development for the city’s energy landscape.
Original reporting: Capitol City Now (WTAX 1240 Springfield) — read the source article.