During a confirmation hearing in Washington, Acting Navy Secretary Hung Cao defended President Trump’s memorandum directing the Navy to develop a plan to replace the newer electromagnetic launch system (EMALS) with traditional steam‑powered catapults on future aircraft carriers. The hearing, held by the Senate Armed Services Committee, highlighted the administration’s effort to address what it calls costly delays in carrier construction.
Trump’s directive and the Navy’s response
In August, President Trump issued a memorandum ordering the Navy to explore a return to steam catapults, arguing that the electromagnetic system and advanced weapons elevators have caused “cost growth, delays, and cancellations” on the Ford‑class carriers. Cao said the delays associated with EMALS and electromagnetic elevators have pushed carrier delivery timelines back by about seven years, leaving the fleet short of the intended ten ships.
“At this point, because of the delays with EMALS and electromagnetic elevators, it’s delaying our carriers by seven years,” Cao told the committee. “We’re going to have five years where we’re down to nine carriers, and I’m trying to accelerate that.” He emphasized that the administration’s plan aims to get the next generation of carriers back on schedule and preserve the Navy’s global reach.
Opposition from Democrats and some Republicans
Virginia Senator Tim Kaine (D) questioned Cao on whether he agreed with the president’s push to revert to steam technology. Kaine reiterated his opposition, warning that a return to older systems would increase costs while diminishing carrier capacity. “To go back to an old way of doing – it is going to have an increased cost with diminished capacity,” Kaine said.
Republican Senator Roger Wicker (R‑Mississippi), the committee’s chairman, also pushed back, calling a return to steam a “non‑starter” and urging the Navy to focus on modern solutions. “Secretary Cao, returning to steam is a non‑starter, and everybody needs to understand that,” Wicker stated.
Despite the bipartisan criticism, Senate Republicans did not include the steam‑catapult initiative in their proposed defense budget, signaling limited legislative support for the proposal.
Administration’s defense
A White House spokesperson told the Associated Press that President Trump has “fixed critical long-term issues in Navy shipbuilding, and will continue to restore American maritime dominance.” The administration argues that steam catapults, a proven technology from earlier carrier classes, can be fielded more quickly and at lower cost than the still‑maturing EMALS.
When asked whether the debate over steam catapults is settled, Senator Kaine said, “From an appropriation standpoint, it’s done. Now that should mean that it’s done, but we do have an administration that has been pretty creative, and I’m using a diplomatic term, in pulling funds from here to there.” This comment underscores the ongoing tension between the administration’s budgetary maneuvers and congressional oversight.
Implications for the fleet and the nation
If the Trump administration’s plan moves forward, the Navy could see a shift in its carrier construction strategy, potentially affecting shipyard schedules at Newport News Shipbuilding and other facilities. Proponents argue that steam catapults could reduce procurement costs and speed up delivery, while critics warn that the technology lacks the flexibility and future‑proofing of electromagnetic systems.
The debate reflects a broader conversation about how the United States balances proven legacy systems with cutting‑edge innovation in its defense posture. As the hearing concluded, the Senate will continue to weigh the fiscal and operational merits of the proposal, with the final decision likely hinging on future budget negotiations and the Navy’s own technical assessments.
Original reporting: WTKR News 3 (Scripps) – local — read the source article.