The South Carolina Judicial Merit Selection Commission (JMSC) announced Thursday that Alan D. Clemmons, the Master-in-Equity for Horry County, does not meet the commission’s qualifications for a new six‑year term. Clemmons, who has served in the role since 2022, will be able to complete his existing term, which expires on July 31, 2027, but he will not be eligible for reappointment.
Background on the Master‑in‑Equity position
The Master‑in‑Equity presides over Horry County’s Equity Court, a division of the circuit court that handles non‑jury matters referred by circuit judges. The docket is dominated by mortgage foreclosure and other property‑related cases, including the county’s foreclosure sales.
JMSC findings and process
The JMSC evaluates candidates on nine criteria: constitutional qualifications, ethical fitness, professional and academic ability, character, reputation, physical health, mental stability, experience, and judicial temperament. In the latest screening cycle, nine candidates were listed on the commission’s report page. Eight were found qualified; Clemmons was the sole exception.
Clemmons was the only candidate for the Horry County seat, and his not‑qualified rating effectively ends his path to a new term. The commission’s decision follows a public hearing process that began on November 16, 2026.
Clemmons’ political and legal history
Before becoming a judge, Clemmons served 18 years in the South Carolina House of Representatives, representing Horry County. While a legislator, he authored the controversial “MBACC TDF” legislation, a 1 % tax for the Myrtle Beach Area Chamber of Commerce that passed without a voter referendum. Critics noted that $22,000 in sequentially marked cashier’s checks were delivered to lawmakers, including former MBACC President Brad Dean, to secure passage of the bill.
Clemmons also chaired the JMSC during a prior selection cycle, a fact that has drawn criticism given the commission’s current decision.
Implications for the court and the community
The Equity Court’s workload will continue under the remaining qualified masters‑in‑equity from Beaufort to York County. With Clemmons’ term ending in mid‑2027, the commission will likely open a new search for a replacement to ensure the court’s docket proceeds without interruption.
Local attorneys and property owners have expressed concern that the uncertainty surrounding the master‑in‑equity seat could affect foreclosure proceedings and related property matters. However, the commission’s report emphasizes that the court’s operations will remain functional while a new candidate is identified.
Response from Clemmons and supporters
Clemmons has not publicly disputed the commission’s findings. Supporters point to his long service in the state legislature and his legal background as evidence of his capability to manage the Equity Court’s responsibilities.
Regardless of differing opinions, the JMSC’s decision reflects its statutory duty to assess candidates against established standards. The commission, now composed of 12 members—half of whom are legislators—asserts that its findings are based on objective criteria rather than political considerations.
Next steps
The JMSC will continue to review applications for the Horry County master‑in‑equity seat as the next screening cycle approaches. Interested candidates should monitor the commission’s announcements for upcoming filing deadlines and hearing dates.
Original reporting: MyrtleBeachSC News — read the source article.