Schnarr’s Gun Shop on North Green River Road is one of those places that runs entirely on reputation. Dave Schnarr opened it in 1987, and in Evansville’s gun-owning community, that name carries weight. This is not a big-box sporting goods counter where someone in a polo shirt reads the serial number off a tag. It is a working gunsmith’s shop, and the difference is obvious the moment you pull into the small lot.
When you walk in, you are likely to find Dave or one of his guys at the bench behind the counter, actually doing something — fitting a grip, checking a trigger pull, or running a bore scope down a barrel. The shop is compact and functional. Glass cases run along the front with a mix of used handguns, revolvers, and a few long guns, priced honestly. The walls hold accessories and cleaning supplies, nothing decorative. If you have come in looking for a particular used firearm, ask. The inventory turns over regularly, and what is in the case on a Monday may be gone by Thursday.
The real draw is the repair and gunsmithing side of the business. If you have inherited a shotgun whose action is sticky, or a carry pistol whose extractor has started misbehaving, this is where people around Evansville bring it. Dave has seen just about everything, and you will not get a blank stare when you describe an unusual problem with an old revolver or a surplus military pistol. The turnaround on straightforward jobs is generally reasonable, though busy stretches — before deer season, in particular — can stretch the timeline. Call ahead and ask honestly about the current wait.
Pricing on gunsmithing work is fair and explained clearly. You will not get a vague estimate and then a surprise at pickup. If the job turns out to be more involved than the initial look suggested, Dave will call you before proceeding. That kind of shop practice sounds basic, but it is not universal, and it is part of why people drive from Warrick County, Gibson County, and across the river from Henderson to bring their work here.
The used firearms selection skews practical rather than collectible, though interesting pieces do show up. Blued steel revolvers, well-worn 1911s, bolt-action hunting rifles in common calibers — the kind of guns that were actually used rather than stored. If you are shopping, bring cash or expect a standard credit card fee. Prices are marked but not rigid; a reasonable conversation is possible if you are serious.
You should know going in that this is a no-frills operation. There is no website worth consulting, no Instagram presence, no online inventory. The phone number works. The best way to find out what is in stock or whether Dave can take on your project is to call during business hours or stop in. Hours can vary slightly, so calling first saves a wasted trip.
What makes Schnarr’s worth knowing about is straightforward: decades of focused, honest work in one specialty, in one city, with a customer base that keeps coming back. That is about as reliable a recommendation as a shop can earn.