San Francisco – On Wednesday, Judge Eric Fleming signed a plea agreement that effectively ends the criminal case against Troy McAlister, the man whose 2020 crash killed two pedestrians and became a rallying point in the recall of former District Attorney Chesa Boudin.
Plea terms and sentencing
The deal calls for a total sentence of 21 years and four months, but McAlister will receive credit for the time he has already spent in custody. The sentencing hearing is set for December, at which point the court will calculate the exact credit.
Under the agreement, McAlister is convicted of two counts of “gross vehicular manslaughter while intoxicated,” carrying a base term of ten years, and one count related to the stolen vehicle, adding eight months. Because of a prior conviction, the ten‑year and eight‑month term is doubled under California’s repeat‑offender statutes.
The 2020 crash
On December 31, 2020, McAlister, then on parole, stole a woman’s car after meeting her on a dating app. While allegedly high on methamphetamine, he ran a red light at the intersection of Second and Mission streets, striking two pedestrians – 27‑year‑old Hanako Abe and 60‑year‑old Elizabeth Platt – both of whom died at the scene.
McAlister grew up in Bayview and had been in and out of prison since age 19 for drug and theft offenses. He was on parole at the time of the crash and had previously been arrested for a 2015 armed robbery, which made him eligible for California’s “three‑strike” law.
Political backdrop
The case gained national attention because it was used by opponents of then‑DA Chesa Boudin to argue that his progressive policies on sentencing were endangering public safety. Boudin had opposed the three‑strike rule and instructed prosecutors to focus on the specific crime rather than prior records, resulting in McAlister’s 2015 robbery sentence being reduced to time already served.
After Boudin’s recall in 2022, former prosecutor Brooke Jenkins succeeded him. An investigation later revealed that Jenkins had improperly forwarded confidential McAlister case files to a colleague’s personal email in 2021, a breach that was cited in recall campaign materials.
Family reactions
Victims’ families expressed mixed feelings about the plea. Alison Platt, sister of Elizabeth Platt, thanked the court for avoiding a lengthy trial and providing closure. In contrast, Hiroko Abe, mother of Hanako Abe, said she would have preferred a trial to fully expose the circumstances, but appreciated the court’s effort to bring the case to a conclusion.
Speaking through a Japanese‑language interpreter, Abe told the court, “It isn’t that I’m seeking a long sentence against McAlister. What I am seeking now is to make public and make clear what happened so that the citizens would understand the term of his sentence, so that the people of San Francisco can live in safety.”
Legal perspective
Assistant District Attorney Kourtney Bell, who helped negotiate the plea, described the agreement as “fair” and “reasonable” given the facts. Judge Fleming echoed that sentiment, noting the plea reflects the seriousness of the offense while accounting for time already served.
The case underscores ongoing concerns about parole supervision, drug enforcement, and the balance between criminal‑justice reform and public safety – issues that remain central to San Francisco’s local discourse.
Original reporting: Mission Local — read the source article.