Chicago City Council approved a measure on Wednesday to hire professional services firms for an independent review of the city’s financial statements. The 45-5 vote, led by Finance Committee Chair Alderman Pat Dowell (3rd), aims to provide “unvarnished truth” about the city’s fiscal condition after Chief Financial Officer Ashlee Gabrysch resigned.
Background to the resignation
Gabrysch stepped down after just three months, stating that remaining in her role would compromise her integrity and professional obligations. She cited disagreements with Mayor Brandon Johnson’s characterizations of his proposed 2027 budget solutions.
Her departure marks the third CFO turnover in less than a year and occurs amid a contentious budget showdown between the mayor and a council majority that opposes key provisions of the proposed spending plan.
Mayor’s response
Mayor Johnson, along with acting CFO and Comptroller Michael Belsky, downplayed the resignation as a personnel mismatch. “I wish her well. This clearly was not the right fit,” Johnson said. “There’s nothing surreptitious about our budgetary process.” Belsky added that the controversy surrounding the budget’s structural balance is “much ado about nothing” and merely a matter of interpretation.
Council’s rationale for an outside review
Dowell, who was appointed by Johnson in 2023 but has become a frequent critic, emphasized the need for full transparency as alderpeople work to pass a 2027 budget by year‑end. “We must know the facts and bolster confidence in the city’s operations,” she said, quoting her mother’s proverb, “Where there’s smoke, there’s fire.” Alderman Brendan Reilly (42nd) said the review will examine emails, memos, presentations, and powerpoints to ensure accuracy and prevent any effort to hide facts.
While the review will not be a comprehensive audit, Dowell indicated the council could use its subpoena power to compel testimony if necessary.
Opposition and criticism
Some aldermen, including Aldermen William Hall (6th), David Moore (17th), Byron Sigcho‑Lopez (25th), Jason Ervin (28th) and Rossana Rodriguez‑Sanchez (33rd), voted against the measure. Ervin dismissed the review as “political theater” and a waste of resources, joking, “It’s silly season at silly hall.”
The mayor’s office, however, said it “welcomes an independent audit of the City’s finances in accordance with professionally accepted standards for municipal finance.”
Budget implications
The council’s move comes as negotiations over the mayor’s corporate head tax and a proposed increase to the Personal Property Lease Transaction Tax continue. Johnson proposes raising the lease tax from 15 % to 20 %, potentially generating about $234 million. The tax would remain at 15 % for vehicle leases and be reduced to 11 % for film and television productions.
Last week, 28 alderpeople urged Johnson to revisit his budget proposal, stating the required 26 votes for approval do not exist. In response, Johnson said his office is developing new models for the lease tax and a reimbursement program related to the head tax.
Credit rating warning
S&P Global warned that the ongoing budget stalemate could trigger a negative credit downgrade for Chicago within 90 days, noting the likelihood of significant one‑time measures to balance the 2027 budget.
The council’s decision to fund the review from its finance committee budget underscores the urgency alderpeople feel to restore public trust in the city’s financial leadership.
Original reporting: Block Club Chicago — read the source article.