Two high‑school runners from Washington state have filed a request to intervene in the ongoing lawsuit that seeks to block Initiative 638, the voter‑approved law that keeps biological males out of girls’ sports. The athletes, members of the nonprofit Female Athletes United, argue that their voices must be heard in the courtroom because they are directly affected by the outcome.
Legal request filed by Alliance Defending Freedom
Alliance Defending Freedom (ADF) attorney Jonathan Scruggs told The Center Square that the group is asking a King County Superior Court judge to allow Female Athletes United to join the case. “It’s appropriate that those most affected by this situation, which is the girls…that they should be the ones who have their voices heard before the court,” Scruggs said.
Initiative 638 was approved by Washington voters on Nov. 3, 2024, passing 56% to 44% – more than 379,000 votes in favor. The measure took effect Dec. 3, unless a court issues an injunction.
Opposition lawsuit and state defense
Last week the ACLU of Washington, Legal Voice and Pacifica Law Group filed a suit in King County Superior Court on behalf of the Washington Education Association, arguing that the law would force transgender students to disclose private medical information and could expose intersex children to unnecessary testing.
Washington Attorney General Nick Brown appointed the law firm Bryan Cave Leighton Paisner (BCLP) to defend the initiative, citing a potential conflict of interest and a desire to keep his office focused on equal‑protection issues for transgender people. Critics, including initiative sponsor Let’s Go Washington, noted that BCLP previously fought against Missouri’s limits on gender‑affirming surgeries for minors, suggesting the firm would be more likely to strike the law down than defend it.
Athletes’ personal statements
Two of the athletes seeking intervention, Sierra Retzlaff and Charlie Garrett, described their experiences on the cross‑country course. Retzlaff wrote, “I do not think it is right or fair to let a male compete in girls’ races based on identifying as female. Males can naturally run faster than girls…If girls do not have separate teams, eventually all the top runners will be biological boys.”
Garrett added, “At the district meet I was in second place most of the race. In the last 600 meters I heard heavy footsteps behind me. It was the Camas runner, and he put on extra speed to pass me…There was no way for me to run as fast as he sprinted to the finish line.”
Local school districts move forward
Despite the pending litigation, the Kennewick School District Board announced Monday that it will implement Initiative 638, noting that more than 73% of voters in the district precincts supported the measure. The board said it will not delay or suspend implementation simply because a lawsuit has been filed.
The Battle Ground School District is considering a similar action. Mother Sheona Lowe, whose 15‑year‑old daughter is a cross‑country runner, urged the Battle Ground School Board to adopt a resolution to enforce I‑638 at its Nov. 23 meeting.
What’s next?
Scruggs expects the plaintiffs to request a temporary hold on the law while the case proceeds, and he warned that the matter is likely to be appealed and could reach the Washington State Supreme Court.
The fight over Initiative 638 highlights the ongoing debate in Washington over how to protect the integrity of girls’ athletics while respecting the rights of transgender and intersex students. As the legal battle unfolds, the voices of the young athletes themselves are now part of the courtroom discussion.
Original reporting: Clark County Today (Vancouver WA) — read the source article.