On Thursday the South Carolina Board of Paroles and Pardons will hear a parole request from Susan Smith, who was convicted in 1995 of two counts of murder for the deaths of her two young sons, 3‑year‑old Michael and 14‑month‑old Alexander. The case, which shocked the state in the mid‑1990s, continues to draw strong emotions from the victims’ family.
Ex‑husband’s plea for life‑long incarceration
David Smith, 56, spoke to CNN ahead of the hearing, saying, “If I have a choice, I’d want her to stay in prison until she dies. 32 years hasn’t changed the heartache.” He added that he never felt any remorse from his former wife and that she never expressed remorse to him.
Legal background and parole eligibility
When Susan Smith was sentenced, South Carolina law allowed parole consideration after 30 years of a life sentence. The legislature amended the statute shortly after her conviction, making anyone sentenced to life for a murder committed after Jan. 1, 1996 ineligible for parole. Because Smith’s crimes occurred in 1994, she remains eligible for a parole review.
Details of the 1994 murders
According to prosecutors, Smith strapped the two boys into a car and let it roll into a lake, causing their deaths. The motive presented by the state was that Smith sought to win back a lover who did not want a relationship with a woman who had children. The defense argued that Smith was in a fragile mental state, suffering from severe depression, and characterized the act as a failed suicide attempt that also claimed the lives of her sons.
Parole board’s prior consideration
Smith’s first parole request was denied in 2024 after David Smith testified that she deliberately killed their children. The board noted the seriousness of the crime and the lasting impact on the victims’ family. The upcoming hearing will again weigh the possibility of release after more than three decades of incarceration.
Community response
The case continues to resonate with South Carolina residents, many of whom recall the tragic media coverage at the time. Local faith leaders have spoken about the need for forgiveness and healing, while others emphasize the importance of justice for the innocent lives lost.
What to expect
The parole board’s decision will be made public after the hearing. If granted, Smith would be placed on supervised release with strict conditions. If denied, she will remain in prison for the remainder of her natural life, as her ex‑husband has urged.
Original reporting: Fox News (HLL/CB) — read the source article.