California Senators Dianne Padilla and Adam Schiff announced a formal Senate inquiry into the Trump administration’s recent withholding of federal Medicaid funds, including more than $3.4 billion earmarked for California’s In‑Home Supportive Services (IHSS) program. The inquiry challenges the administration’s claim that the funding freeze is a necessary step in a broader effort to combat Medicaid fraud.
Administration’s Rationale
In a letter to the senators, Dr. Mehmet Oz, Administrator of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services’ Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS), emphasized that CMS is conducting “the most aggressive public enforcement campaign against state Medicaid programs in the agency’s history.” He argued that the freeze targets “corrupt individuals and organizations masquerading as health‑care providers” who defraud Medicaid and American taxpayers, diverting resources from low‑income seniors, children and disabled individuals.
Oz also noted that the administration’s focus is on “providers without National Provider Identifiers” and other high‑risk categories, asserting that decisive action is required to protect the program’s integrity.
Senators’ Concerns
Padilla and Schiff contend that the administration’s actions amount to “political theater layered over a decade of neglect,” accusing the federal government of dismantling the very infrastructure Congress funded to prevent Medicaid fraud. They point to the lack of specific evidence of wrongdoing in California’s IHSS program, despite a 17.5 percent increase in caseloads from 613,764 in FY 2022‑23 to 720,988 in FY 2024‑25.
The senators also highlight that the average hourly cost for IHSS services rose from $19.00 to $21.03—a 10.7 percent increase—driven by statewide minimum‑wage hikes and county‑negotiated rates, not fraud.
Federal Oversight Changes
In March, President Trump signed Executive Order 14395, creating a task force led by the Vice President to eliminate Medicaid fraud. The order states that some states have “embraced loopholes” that allow self‑certification of eligibility and expand enrollment beyond congressional intent. The administration argues that these loopholes enable illegal immigrants, criminal networks, and other bad actors to exploit the system, increasing waste and the national debt.
Critics, however, note that the executive order also placed all Medicaid Fraud Control Units under review and replaced them with a “Medicaid Fraud ‘War Room,’” which the administration describes as “what modern program integrity looks like.” Senators argue that Congress mandated a minimum of $75 million and at least 100 full‑time staff for the Medicaid Integrity Program, obligations they say cannot be treated as optional.
Impact on Californians
The IHSS program is a cornerstone of California’s home‑and‑community‑based services, allowing seniors and disabled residents to remain safely at home rather than entering costly institutional settings. The California Department of Health Care Services stresses that the program aligns with federal policy and the Americans with Disabilities Act, and that the recent growth reflects genuine increases in need, not fraud.
While the administration maintains that withholding funds is a necessary safeguard, the senators’ inquiry seeks documentation of any specific fraud findings that justified the freeze, as well as a review of the administration’s broader strategy for Medicaid oversight.
What Comes Next
The Senate committee plans to hold hearings with CMS officials, state health agencies, and independent experts to assess the validity of the administration’s claims and the impact of the funding suspension on vulnerable Californians. The outcome could shape future federal‑state collaboration on Medicaid integrity and influence how the administration balances fraud prevention with the delivery of essential services.
Original reporting: KEYT (Ventura/Santa Barbara) — read the source article.