HELA‑WEST HELENA, Ark. – A special judge has concluded that Phillips County intentionally masked the salary of longtime prosecutor’s office employee Nita Murray by listing it under a budget line labeled “Supplies.” The arrangement kept her off the county payroll and denied her retirement contributions through the Arkansas Public Employees Retirement System (APERS).
Judge finds employee status and orders retroactive retirement credit
Retired Circuit Judge Robert Bynum Gibson Jr. determined that Murray was a county employee from September 1, 1993, through her retirement on December 31, 2021. He ordered the county to fund retirement contributions for the full period, which had not been credited to APERS.
The judge’s 13‑page factual findings, filed September 17, were incorporated into a final declaratory judgment and writ of mandamus entered on October 1, after a bench trial on June 9.
Salary paid through husband, not on payroll
According to the findings, Phillips County appropriated $15,125 for Murray’s salary but recorded the expense under the “Supplies” line. The money was paid to her husband, Deputy Prosecuting Attorney Todd Murray, who then paid her.
Judge Gibson said the scheme was an intentional effort to avoid recognizing Murray as a county employee and enrolling her in APERS because she is white.
Employment facts support employee status
The judge noted that Murray worked in the courthouse, possessed courthouse keys, and received the county employee manual when she started. Testimony described her as a diligent worker who prepared cases for trial, interviewed witnesses, and served as the office’s point of contact for law enforcement.
Former Prosecuting Attorney Fletcher Long testified about budget friction with the Quorum Court, and the judge cited a 2007 letter from Long complaining that the county had reduced the prosecutor’s office budget to a level sufficient for only one month of operation.
Gibson also found that Murray was denied janitorial services, resulting in mold and mildew in her office.
Racial motive evidence disputed
The judge relied in part on a 1999 Quorum Court resolution that directed officials to hire Black applicants for vacancies, interpreting it as an intent to exclude white applicants. County attorneys argued the resolution was unsigned by the county judge and clerk, had no legal effect, and was unrelated to Murray’s case. They also said an earlier EEOC determination involved other employees and did not mention her.
Gibson rejected the argument about the missing signature, finding the resolution had been adopted by acclamation.
Retirement coverage and attorney fees
The October 1 judgment confirmed that Murray’s salary was paid entirely with county appropriations, that she was not an independent contractor, and that she qualified as a county employee for retirement purposes. The judgment identifies August 1, 2018, as the date she was finally added to the official county payroll, but orders credit for service dating back to September 1, 1993.
Under the order, the county must appropriate and remit the unpaid retirement contributions, plus any penalties, interest, or present‑day value determined by APERS, within 30 days of entry. The judgment also directs the county to pay Murray’s reasonable attorney fees and costs; she has requested $50,575 in fees and $2,727.12 in costs.
County appeals the ruling
Phillips County filed a notice of appeal on October 22, challenging the October 1 judgment and the award of attorney fees. The county argues the lawsuit was barred by a three‑year statute of limitations and disputes whether Murray was properly appointed. It also contends that retirement eligibility should be resolved through APERS’s administrative process.
Judge Gibson rejected the county’s immunity argument, stating that recognizing Murray’s status and meeting its retirement obligations was a mandatory duty.
“This case should have never happened. The fault lies entirely with Phillips County Quorum Court and the Phillips County Clerk,” Gibson wrote.
Next steps
The appeal will be assigned to the Arkansas Supreme Court for review. Until the appellate court rules, the county must comply with the order to fund the retirement contributions and related costs.
Original reporting: NEA Report (Jonesboro) — read the source article.