Four separate public‑records requests this year seeking details on Idaho’s Parental Choice Tax Credit were turned down by the Idaho State Tax Commission. The requests, including two from Idaho Education News, asked how many credit recipients were previously enrolled in private schools or were homeschooled.
Commission explains lack of data
Commission officials responded that the information simply does not exist. “We didn’t collect this information on private schools,” senior public information officer Renee Eymann said by email. The agency only records whether a student was previously enrolled in an Idaho public school, not whether they attended a private or non‑public institution.
When the commission released a report on Friday, it revealed that nearly 75% of tax‑credit applicants indicated on their applications that they had never attended an Idaho public school. The figure sparked speculation that most of those students must have come from private schools or homeschooling backgrounds.
Why the requests missed the mark
According to Eymann, the commission’s data collection focuses solely on prior public‑school enrollment. The records requests, however, asked for data on prior private‑school enrollment, a metric the agency does not track. “We didn’t collect this information on private schools,” she reiterated.
Idaho Education News noted that the agency’s limited data collection made the requests technically out of bounds. The newsroom’s earlier attempts in April and July to obtain the private‑school enrollment numbers were therefore denied on a technicality.
Implications for families and policymakers
The Parental Choice Tax Credit, created by House Bill 93, aims to give families a tax incentive to send children to private schools or to homeschool. Without data on how many credit recipients are shifting from private or home education to public schools—or vice versa—policymakers lack a clear picture of the program’s impact on Idaho’s public‑school system.
Critics of the credit argue that it diverts resources away from public schools, while supporters contend it expands educational freedom for families seeking alternatives that align with their faith and values. The commission’s refusal to provide the requested data leaves both sides without concrete evidence to support their positions.
What could improve transparency
EdNews suggested that future records requests be more precisely worded to match the data the commission actually collects. Alternatively, the commission could clarify its data‑collection practices, helping the public understand what information is available and what is not.
For now, families, advocates, and legislators will have to rely on the limited statistic that 75% of applicants have never attended an Idaho public school, a figure that may include preschoolers, recent movers, and first‑time kindergarteners.
The lack of detailed enrollment data underscores a broader challenge: ensuring transparency while respecting the practical limits of state‑run data systems. As the debate over school choice continues in Idaho, stakeholders will likely push for clearer reporting standards to better assess the credit’s effectiveness.
Original reporting: Idaho Education News — read the source article.