On a weeknight in late June, around 7:30, the line at Roxy’s Ice Cream Social stretches past the front door and onto the sidewalk along Douglas Avenue. You’re standing in it. The evening is still warm, the kind where the air barely moves, and the couple in front of you is debating between the lavender honey and something involving brown butter. They’ve clearly been here before. Everyone in this line has.
Roxy’s opened in 2013 and has stayed quietly, stubbornly excellent ever since. Owner and maker Roxanne Klein runs the shop out of a cheerful space in the College Hill neighborhood, and the ice cream she produces from scratch is the kind you don’t eat while walking and scrolling your phone. You slow down. You notice it.
Klein rotates flavors constantly, and that’s the first thing you should know before you go. The menu shifts with the season and her mood, which sounds precious but isn’t — it means you’re eating something that was made recently, with intention, and probably not available anywhere else in Wichita. In summer, expect things like fresh peach, sweet corn, or Vietnamese coffee. In fall, she’ll lean into spiced apple or pumpkin with a salty caramel swirl that makes the whole thing taste like the best version of a thing you’ve loved your whole life.
The secondthing you should know: get a cup, not a cone. The scoops here are generous, and the cones, while fine, don’t do the ice cream any favors. A cup lets you actually taste what Klein is working with — real cream, real fruit, no artificial anything. A single scoop runs around four dollars, a double around six. It’s not cheap by ice cream standards, but it’s cheap by any other standard you care to apply.
If you bring kids, they will find the place immediately comfortable — small tables, bright colors, friendly counter staff who don’t rush you through your decision. If you come without kids, you’ll appreciate that it somehow doesn’t feel chaotic even when it’s packed. Klein has arranged the space smartly, and her staff keeps things moving without pushing anyone out the door.
The shop also makes ice cream sandwiches using freshly baked cookies, and if the brown butter chocolate chip version is on the board when you walk in, don’t walk past it. That sandwich alone explains why Roxy’s keeps regulars who’ve lived in Wichita for decades and newcomers who found out about the place inside their first week in town.
Parking on Douglas can be annoying on busy nights — your best bet is the side streets. The shop closes earlier than you might expect, usually around 9 or 10 depending on the season, so don’t assume you can wander in at ten. Check their Instagram the day you plan to go; Klein posts the current flavors there, and knowing what’s available before you arrive will spare you a moment of paralysis at the counter.
It’s the kind of place that earns loyalty without asking for it. Klein doesn’t do a lot of marketing, doesn’t need to, and doesn’t seem particularly interested in growing into something larger than what she has. What she has is working. You’ll understand why before you finish your first scoop.