Polk County, Fla. – On Saturday afternoon, a routine traffic stop by Polk County Sheriff’s deputies ended a series of retail thefts targeting Hanes basics at discount stores in Poinciana. The stop, made around 4 p.m. on November 14, 2026, resulted in the arrest of 39‑year‑old Matthew Markell Williams, a resident of nearby Kissimmee.
Background and investigation
Williams was already wanted on an outstanding Orange County warrant for failing to appear in court on a petit theft charge. Detectives quickly connected him to three recent incidents along Marigold Avenue in Poinciana, each involving a distinct focus on Hanes apparel.
The alleged thefts began on October 16 at the Family Dollar located at 6501 Marigold Ave., where Williams is said to have taken three three‑packs of Hanes T‑shirts. Three days later, on October 19, he allegedly returned to the Dollar General at 8500 Marigold Ave., walking away with roughly $300 worth of Hanes underwear, socks and T‑shirts. The final incident occurred on November 10 when Williams returned to the original Family Dollar, broke a security tag off another pack of Hanes T‑shirts, but left the store empty‑handed.
Arrest and charges
Following the traffic stop, deputies transported Williams to the Polk County Sheriff’s Processing Center. He was booked on the Orange County warrant and now faces charges for each of the three Polk County retail thefts. The sheriff’s office noted that Williams’s prior criminal history includes burglary, battery and narcotics offenses, marking his recent focus on “fresh laundry” as a notable shift in his criminal pattern.
Community impact
Local merchants expressed relief that the suspect was apprehended, emphasizing the importance of swift law‑enforcement action to protect small businesses. The Polk County Sheriff’s Office praised the deputies for their vigilance and coordination with Orange County authorities, underscoring the collaborative effort required to address cross‑jurisdictional crime.
Residents of Poinciana and the surrounding area are encouraged to report suspicious activity and to remain vigilant in protecting their neighborhoods. The sheriff’s office continues to advise shoppers to be aware of security measures and to contact law enforcement if they observe theft or other criminal behavior.
Next steps
Williams will appear before a Polk County judge for a probable cause hearing. If convicted, he faces penalties consistent with Florida statutes governing petit theft and repeat offenses. The sheriff’s office will continue to monitor retail theft trends and work with local businesses to deter future incidents.
Original reporting: Tampa Free Press — read the source article.