Monroe Township, New Jersey, is at the center of a federal lawsuit that could reshape local zoning authority across the country, including in Horry and Georgetown counties. The township’s Ordinance O:25-2026, which prohibits data centers in every zoning district, is being challenged by construction firm Hexa Builders, which argues the ban violates the First Amendment and equal‑protection clauses.
Tech Justice Law, a tech‑accountability organization, filed an amicus brief in the U.S. District Court for the District of New Jersey urging the judge to reject Hexa’s constitutional claims. According to myrtlebeachnews.com, the brief asserts that “the people of Monroe Township have used their First Amendment‑protected freedom of speech to speak up against data centers,” and that “Hexa Builders’ bricks do not have that same right,” said Meetali Jain, founding executive director of Tech Justice Law.
Hexa Builders contends that the ordinance treats data centers differently from other warehouse and storage facilities, violating equal protection, and that data centers powering artificial‑intelligence systems constitute a “medium of communication and expression,” thus invoking free‑speech protections. The company had previously secured approval to construct warehouses on the disputed property and later sought to convert one building into a data center without a tenant in place.
The amicus brief counters both arguments. It maintains that constructing and operating a data center is not expressive activity, that data centers are not mediums of communication, and that AI output does not automatically become speech. Accepting Hexa’s theory, the brief warns, would subject ordinary zoning decisions about power plants, warehouses and other infrastructure to First Amendment scrutiny.
Legal scholars quoted in the brief support the township’s position. Olivier Sylvain, a professor at Fordham University School of Law, described the ordinance as “a prudent exercise of democratic initiative” against facilities he called “disproportionately extractive and costly for local residents.” Laura Bingham, practice professor of law at Temple University and executive director of the Institute for Law, Innovation, and Technology, said local communities are “where the AI industry is meeting the democratic process in this country.”
For Myrtle Beach residents, the case matters because a ruling that extends free‑speech protection to data centers could make it more difficult for Horry and Georgetown county councils to deny similar projects. Local officials routinely weigh water use, power demand, noise and electricity costs—issues highlighted in the brief and already raised by Grand Strand residents concerned about rapid growth.
What’s next: The judge may consider the amicus brief, but is not bound by its arguments. The lawsuit remains pending in federal court in Camden, New Jersey. Myrtle Beach readers should monitor any proposals for data‑center or AI‑related facilities that appear before Horry County Council, Georgetown County Council, or city planning commissions, as the outcome could influence future zoning decisions in the region.
Sources: myrtlebeachnews.com