New Plymouth, Idaho – Residents of the small town are growing increasingly frustrated that the debris from the November 24, 2025 fire that destroyed the Double Diamond Saloon and the adjacent Shear Attitude Salon remains on the property nearly a year later. Long‑time community member Jan Holshevnikoff said she has contacted state and federal officials without receiving a clear answer, prompting her to turn to local news outlet Idaho News 6 for help.
“Nothing has happened, so I don’t know who else to go to,” Holshevnikoff told reporters. “They’re sick and tired of this.” She recalled the saloon’s role as a gathering place for holiday parties and steak dinners, underscoring how the loss has affected the town’s social fabric.
Volunteer efforts stalled
Local resident Justin Cherry posted a video on Facebook asking, “When is somebody gonna take care of this?” His online appeal attracted offers of dumpsters, equipment and volunteers, but the cleanup never began. Cherry said volunteers were told not to enter the site without documentation after speaking with the bar’s owner. Idaho News 6 could not independently verify why the effort was halted.
Environmental concerns
Neighbors also worry about a blocked sidewalk and the potential for rain‑washed debris to enter a nearby storm drain that feeds the Payette River. The Idaho Department of Environmental Quality (DEQ) confirmed it has received complaints and is investigating, but it has not yet tested the debris or runoff. DEQ officials stated they have found no environmental hazards or violations and have no evidence of a Clean Water Act breach, though they noted EPA Region 10 is aware of asbestos concerns raised by residents.
City response
Attempts to reach Mayor Tyson Flannery resulted in a visit to City Hall where the clerk said officials are awaiting guidance from the city’s legal team. Public Works Superintendent Beau Ziemer also referred questions to the mayor. As of this publication, the city has not provided a substantive response outlining a cleanup timeline or how it intends to use its enforcement authority.
City Council records show that in December 2025 the council voted to declare the Double Diamond a dangerous building requiring demolition and removal once investigations allow. Local code sets deadlines for removing demolition debris and provides a process for the city to address a nuisance and seek repayment from the property owner.
Ownership and legal matters
The Idaho State Fire Marshal’s Office confirmed its investigation remains active and no final finding on the fire’s origin has been issued. Consequently, no final report is available, and the agency has not clarified whether demolition or debris removal can proceed while the investigation is open.
NEFCO Fire Investigations, identified on a sign at the property, declined to disclose details, describing the case as a private investigation. The company suggested the owner or the insurance company could have hired them, but did not name a client.
County assessor records list Lost Creek Investments as the property owner, with a manager or member identified as Cusma. A recorded notice predating the fire shows a lender filed a lawsuit seeking foreclosure of a mortgage on the site. Idaho News 6 has not confirmed whether that litigation is affecting cleanup efforts, and Cusma has not responded to multiple requests for comment.
Community calls for action
Local resident Ginny Barton, who has been gathering public records and contacting officials, said the lack of answers is “frustrating.” She added, “That’s why we’re trying to make noise because we really appreciate you guys giving us a chance to be heard.” Barton summed up the community’s goal: “Right now we just want it cleaned up.”
Idaho News 6 will continue to seek records and responses about the steps required before cleanup can proceed and when residents can expect progress.
Original reporting: KIVI Idaho News 6 Boise metro (local) — read the source article.