Jordy Smith, 76, of the City Heights neighborhood in San Diego, recounts how a man she hired to fix a broken pipe took control of her home after she suffered a hip injury. The individual, who was not a licensed plumber, allegedly changed the utility accounts to his name and began renting rooms and RV spaces to more than a dozen people, many appearing to be homeless.
Legal hurdles created by California’s tenant‑protection statutes
Under California law, occupants who remain in a property for 30 days acquire “tenant‑at‑will” rights. Once that threshold is met, law enforcement must treat the situation as a civil landlord‑tenant matter rather than criminal trespassing, requiring a formal eviction process. Squatter Squad, a private squatter‑removal firm hired by Smith, explained that this legal framework often delays homeowners’ ability to reclaim their property.
“California’s tenant protection laws serve an important purpose, but they can also create unintended challenges when individuals unlawfully occupy properties,” said Lando Thomas, owner of Squatter Squad. “When the distinction cannot be established immediately, property owners may be forced into lengthy and costly legal proceedings.”
Removal effort and homeowner’s plea for reform
After months of being locked out, Smith and her partner worked with the San Diego County Sheriff’s Office. Deputies confronted the occupants in August, and after following the required legal eviction process, the property was finally returned to the rightful owners.
Smith urges state legislators to amend the law to prevent similar situations, stating, “Make some new laws and take care of the legitimate people that are having the problems because it really has caused a lot of stress for us.”
The case underscores the tension between protecting lawful tenants and preventing exploitation of tenant‑at‑will provisions, a balance that California lawmakers continue to grapple with.
Original reporting: Fox News (HLL/CB) — read the source article.