There are pizza towns, and then there is Buffalo. If you have spent any time talking to a Buffalonian about food — and trust me, they will happily talk about food for hours — you will quickly learn that Buffalo-style pizza is its own glorious category, and Bocce Club Pizza on Sheridan Drive in Amherst is widely regarded as its cathedral.
I made my first visit on a Tuesday evening, which in retrospect was either brilliant or accidental timing. The parking lot was already humming with cars, families were streaming through the door, and the smell hit me before I even reached the entrance — a deep, yeasty, sauce-forward aroma that immediately told me this was going to be a serious meal. Bocce Club has been serving Buffalo since 1946, and walking in, you get the sense that absolutely nothing about the quality has slipped in those nearly eight decades.
So what makes Buffalo-style pizza different? It starts with the crust — medium thickness, with a crisp, almost cracker-like bottom that gives way to a tender, airy interior. Then comes a generous layer of bright, slightly sweet tomato sauce applied on top of the cheese rather than beneath it. Yes, you read that correctly. The sauce goes on last. It sounds like a small detail, but the effect is remarkable: the cheese melts directly into the dough while the sauce stays vivid and fresh on top, giving every bite a clean, bright punch of flavor.
At Bocce Club, the cheese blend is creamy and pulls in satisfying long ribbons. The pepperoni curls at the edges when baked, forming those little crispy cups that every pizza enthusiast quietly obsesses over. I ordered a large pepperoni and a cup of their house salad, which comes with a tangy Italian dressing that locals have been requesting in jars for years. It is the kind of meal where you tell yourself you will save two slices for tomorrow and then absolutely do not.
The atmosphere is no-frills in the best possible way. Booths, a bustling counter, staff who have clearly been doing this for years, and a dining room full of regulars who nod at each other like members of a very delicious club. There is something deeply comforting about eating in a place that has earned that kind of loyalty across multiple generations of the same families.
Bocce Club also offers takeout and delivery, but if you are visiting Buffalo for the first time, eating in is the move. Sit at a booth, take your time, watch the room, and let the pizza do its work. You will leave understanding exactly why Buffalo people get a little misty-eyed about pizza whenever they travel somewhere else.
Sheridan Drive is a short drive from downtown, easily paired with a visit to Delaware Park or the Buffalo Museum of Science. Make it a full Buffalo afternoon, but make sure Bocce Club is the main event.